Defining and Quantifying Natural and Environmental Amenities: a Literature Review
Définir et quantifier les aménités naturelles et environnementales : une revue de la littérature.
Schaeffer, Y. ; Dissart, J.C. ; Tartiu, C.
Type de document
Communication scientifique sans actes
Affiliation de l'auteur
IRSTEA GRENOBLE UR LESSEM FRA ; UNIVERSITE GRENOBLE ALPES CNRS SCIENCES PO GRENOBLE UMR PACTE GRENOBLE FRA ; IRSTEA GRENOBLE UR LESSEM FRA
Résumé / Abstract
This paper takes a step back from the notions of natural amenities and environmental amenities. What are natural and environmental amenities? How are they defined and measured in the scientific literature, and in relations to what research purposes? To answer these questions, we present a review of the (about 225) peer-reviewed quantitative articles published during the period 1989-2013 exhibiting one of these two notions in their titles, abstracts or keywords. We observe a strong trend toward an increasing number of publications per year, and a concentration into five main journals (Ecological Economics being the first). Two main research objectives are followed: recovering implicit prices of natural assets (about 40% of the papers) and understanding their impacts on regional economic development (about 35%). Most articles do not mention any definition of natural or environmental amenities, but move directly to the issue of measuring them. The two notions are not distinguished empirically since they are measured with analogous indicators. Neither are they distinguished theoretically in the papers providing definitions. In these later, we cannot identify a single or even a small set of commonly accepted definitions. Nevertheless, at least seven distinct classes of amenities can be identified, and a huge diversity of measures within each class. Most papers use a set of unidimensional measures of natural/environmental attributes (predominantly landcover/land-use and water-related indicators, and to a lesser extent topographic and climatic indicators). Fewer papers use PCA-based so-called amenity indices, and even fewer multidimensional indicators stemming from ecological science. Natural/environmental disamenities are rarely considered together with natural/environmental amenities.
12th Conference of the European Society for Ecological Economics, 20/06/2017 - 23/06/2017, Budapest, HUN
Proceedings of the 12th Conference of the European Society for Ecological Economics: Programme & Abstract Book