Modelling constructed wetlands: scopes and aims - a comparative review
La modélisation des filtres plantés de roseaux : domaines d'application et objectifs, une revue comparative
Meyer, D. ; Chazarenc, F. ; Claveau Mallet, D. ; Dittmer, D. ; Forquet, N. ; Molle, P. ; Morvannou, A. ; Palfy, T. ; Petitjean, A. ; Rizzo, A. ; Samso Campa, R. ; Scholz, M. ; Soric, A. ; Langergraber, G.
Type de document
Article de revue scientifique à comité de lecture
Affiliation de l'auteur
IRSTEA LYON UR MALY FRA ; ECOLE DES MINES NANTES FRA ; ECOLE POLYTECHNIQUE MONTREAL CAN ; UNIVERSITY OF STUTTGART DEU ; IRSTEA LYON UR MALY FRA ; IRSTEA LYON UR MALY FRA ; EPUR NATURE CAUMONT SUR DURANCE FRA ; EPUR NATURE CAUMONT SUR DURANCE FRA ; IRSTEA LYON UR MALY FRA ; POLITECNICO DI TORINO ITA ; GEMMA BARCELONE ESP ; CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH GROUP UNIVERSITY OF SALFORD GBR ; UNIVERSITE D'AIX MARSEILLE FRA ; UNIVERSITY OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND LIFE SCIENCS VIENNA AUT
Résumé / Abstract
During the last two decades a couple of models were developed for constructed wetlands with differing purposes. Meanwhile the usage of this kind of tool is generally accepted, but the misuse of the models still confirms the skepticism. Generally three some groups of models can be distinguished: On one hand mechanistic models try to display the complex and diffuse interaction of occurring processes, on the other hand the same kind of models is are used to investigate single processes. New kinds of simplified approaches – well appreciated by engineers - try to display system performances without going to deep into details. All types of models are valuable – some more for scientific usage, others more for engineering. The given summary tries to support potential users in talking the right choice in model selection. Big differences can be found in the model availabilities. Whereas some of the compared software packages are purchasable without limitation, some others are only accessible on their platform level, and some can be seen as secret exclusive property. From the experience of the authors it can be summarized, that research groups starting modelling / simulation studies should be encouraged to use the given knowledge before starting from scratch again.
Ecological Engineering, vol. 80, p. 205 - 213